McCaffrey now doing a semi-Murtha?


From ArmyTimes

The U.S. would have to slash combat forces in Iraq to 10 brigades by Christmas to keep the Army from breaking, said retired Army Gen. Barry McCaffrey. See McCaffrey’s GWOT presentation.

Saying he thinks “we’re stuck now,” he acknowledged that pulling out five of the 15 brigades now on duty in Iraq by the end of December is not feasible.

“We can’t precipitously withdraw. It will ignite all-out civil war, possibly among not only Iraq but its six neighbors,” he said in a telephone interview Nov. 16.

McCaffrey predicted that the Army, particularly the National Guard, is on the verge of breaking because the effort is vastly underresourced and cannot be sustained for long.

“You’ve got a foreign policy, a national security policy in Washington and they’re not resourced to carry it out,” said McCaffrey, who called for an increase of 80,000 soldiers and 25,000 Marines in each service. “The country is not at war. The United States armed forces and the CIA are at war. So we are asking our military to sustain a level of effort that we have not resourced,” he told Army Times.

So what is the solution to "winning" our Iraq War?

    * train lots more Iraqi troops and give them up-to-date real weapons and their own logistics support framework? [Hah]

    * reinstitute the draft?

    * adopt Max Boot's 'Alien Freedom Troopers' concept? [lure non-Americans into service by the promise of U.S. citizenship when they completed their tours of duty]

    * hire lots more mercenaries?

    * do lots more air war?

    * other ideas?

And speaking of lots more air war: U.S. Airstrikes Climb Sharply in Afghanistan
--

“It is only those who have neither fired a shot nor heard the shrieks and groans of the wounded who cry aloud for blood, more vengeance, more desolation. War is hell.”--William Tecumseh Sherman

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Do less of everything (#12094)
by dionysus

Except more training and more advisory officers. Take the troop level down to say 80k or so (made up number, I'm not a general) over the next, say, 6 months (ditto), and have every soldier be either a part of an Iraqi unit as an advisor, or part of a rapid reaction force that stays on base most of the time. No "presence patrols", I can't freakin believe that we're still doing those, hey let's go be targets for the afternoon.

It's gonna be a mess for the next 10 years anyways, I don't see why we should sacrifice more than necessary. Lets get out of the way and let them tire themselves out.

McCaffrey, like a lot of smart people, is about half as smart (#12007)
by Ken White

as he thinks he is. He made four stars but as a good freind of mine said, "Anybody with two DSCs is either crazy or a liar." He had a successful career but was very instrumental in getting Bush 41 to decide to call it quits early in Desert Storm. Like most people, he's done some good and some bad. He is not the holy grail.

Here's yet another General more concerned with protecting the institution than in geting the job done. This guy, like Powell, Clark and Franks was almost directly reponsible for the failure of the Army to address counterinsurgency and nation building training for over 30 years; a position that directly caused the failure to chop the insurgency in Iraq off before it got wound up. Thus, I can't get too sympathetic toward his epiphaneous position.

That's the long way of getting to the point -- he underestimates his Army. It ain't easy, there'll be more divorces and more junior officers will leave due to wife pressure -- but the Army won't break, it's pretty resilient.

--

The K Codes explained HERE.

Here is something cool (#11985)
by pumpkin ash

for history of war/empire buffs (educational too):

Imperial history

--

“It is only those who have neither fired a shot nor heard the shrieks and groans of the wounded who cry aloud for blood, more vengeance, more desolation. War is hell.”--William Tecumseh Sherman

Very cool (#12093)
by dionysus

nt

Links

Conservative
Liberal
Moderate/Mixed/Non-Partisan
Non-Political/Reference

Related Sites -

Polisci Applied (Aaron)
Intrepid Liberal Journal (Intrepid Liberal)
Obsidian Wings (Bird Dog)
Open Hand/Open Eye (locutas)
Red State (Bird Dog)
Swords Crossed (brendanm98)
Wagster Speaks (Wagster)
WatchingAmerica (BlaiseP)
The Social Pathologist (TSP)

Foreign Affairs -

Abu Aardvark
'Aqoul
American Footprints
Council on Foreign Relations
CSIS
Democracy Arsenal
Intel Dump
The Fourth Rail
War and Piece

Politics -

Ace of Spades HQ
Andrew Sullivan
Balloon Juice
Belgravia Dispatch
Captain's Quarters
Crooked Timber
Curmudgeonly & Skeptical
Daily Kos
Democracy Arsenal
Eschaton
Firedoglake
Glenn Greenwald
Global Guerrillas
Hugh Hewitt
Instapundit
Jawa Report
Lawyers, Guns and Money
Liberals Against Terror
Matt Yglesias
Michael J. Totten
Michelle Malkin
Moon of Alabama
New America
OxBlog
Patterico
Political Animal
Political Wire
Publius Pundit
QandO
Reality Based Community
Talking Points Memo
The Agitator
The Belmont Club
The Corner
Truman Project
Winds of Change.net

War -

Counterterrorism Blog
Iraq the Model
Jihad Watch
Small Wars Journal Blog

Economics and Business -

Angry Bear
Brad DeLong
Daniel Drezner
Mahalanobis
Marginal Revolution
Roubini Global Economics
The Big Picture

Science and Tech -

Bad Astronomy
New Scientist
Real Climate
Science Blogs
Scientific American
The Panda's Thumb

Legal -

Balkinization
Conglomerate
Ideoblog
Jurisdynamics
Law and Letters
Overlawyered
ProfessorBainbridge
ScotusBlog
Talk Left
The Becker-Posner Blog
Volokh Conspiracy

Sports -

Baseball Crank
Baseball Musings
Baseball Reference.com
ESPN.com
NFL.com
Only Baseball Matters
The Sports Economist

Books, Film and Music -

Amazon.com
Internet Movie Database
All Music Guide

News and Aggregators -

Asia Times
Boingboing
CNN
Digg
English Russia
Fark
Los Angeles Times
Memeorandum
MSNBC
Politico
Poynteronline
Slashdot
The New York Times
The Washington Post

References -

Wikipedia
Your Dictionary