Because Ignorance is not Bliss
First and foremost, talking points don't make an arguement.
Statement of Walter Lukken
Commissioner
U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission
to the FOW Trade Mission –Shanghai
November 21, 2003
Please read the entire article and then we can talk about pork bellies.
Some additional background information on ISDA is probably warranted but...
--
"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Timmy the Wonder Dog's blog
- Login or register to post comments
Conservative
Liberal
Moderate/Mixed/Non-Partisan
Non-Political/Reference
Related Sites -
Polisci Applied (Aaron)
Intrepid Liberal Journal (Intrepid Liberal)
Obsidian Wings (Bird Dog)
Open Hand/Open Eye (locutas)
Red State (Bird Dog)
Swords Crossed (brendanm98)
Wagster Speaks (Wagster)
WatchingAmerica (BlaiseP)
The Social Pathologist (TSP)
Foreign Affairs -
Abu Aardvark
'Aqoul
American Footprints
Council on Foreign Relations
CSIS
Democracy Arsenal
Intel Dump
The Fourth Rail
War and Piece
Politics -
Ace of Spades HQ
Andrew Sullivan
Balloon Juice
Belgravia Dispatch
Captain's Quarters
Crooked Timber
Curmudgeonly & Skeptical
Daily Kos
Democracy Arsenal
Eschaton
Firedoglake
Glenn Greenwald
Global Guerrillas
Hugh Hewitt
Instapundit
Jawa Report
Lawyers, Guns and Money
Liberals Against Terror
Matt Yglesias
Michael J. Totten
Michelle Malkin
Moon of Alabama
New America
OxBlog
Patterico
Political Animal
Political Wire
Publius Pundit
QandO
Reality Based Community
Talking Points Memo
The Agitator
The Belmont Club
The Corner
Truman Project
Winds of Change.net
War -
Counterterrorism Blog
Iraq the Model
Jihad Watch
Small Wars Journal Blog
Economics and Business -
Angry Bear
Brad DeLong
Daniel Drezner
Mahalanobis
Marginal Revolution
Roubini Global Economics
The Big Picture
Science and Tech -
Bad Astronomy
New Scientist
Real Climate
Science Blogs
Scientific American
The Panda's Thumb
Legal -
Balkinization
Conglomerate
Ideoblog
Jurisdynamics
Law and Letters
Overlawyered
ProfessorBainbridge
ScotusBlog
Talk Left
The Becker-Posner Blog
Volokh Conspiracy
Sports -
Baseball Crank
Baseball Musings
Baseball Reference.com
ESPN.com
NFL.com
Only Baseball Matters
The Sports Economist
Books, Film and Music -
Amazon.com
Internet Movie Database
All Music Guide
News and Aggregators -
Asia Times
Boingboing
CNN
Digg
English Russia
Fark
Los Angeles Times
Memeorandum
MSNBC
Politico
Poynteronline
Slashdot
The New York Times
The Washington Post
References -

do you believe that some regulation of derivatives like CDSs would have mitigated or prevented the current crisis? If so, would that protection have been more valuable than the damage caused by the regulation? (seems like it would have been possible to write legislation or whatever to get around voiding existing contracts/obligations)
I'm not arguing with the bipartisan nature of passing CFMA, though.
--"The strongest drive is not love or hate. It is one person's need to edit another's copy."
- Login or register to post comments
)I would answer no.
What protection are you recommending?
Finally, I'm happy that the CFMA myth and legend has been put to rest.
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )How about a reserve requirement if writing a CDS? How about some public disclosure, a la what is being debated by the SEC, like a qualitative description of what the CDS was bought for, how it will hedge risk, what gains it will hopefully produce, etc., by public companies? These would probably right there make them much safer and more sane instruments of risk management, and limit the speculation.
I'd question you on dismissing CDS' role in the current crisis. Not being able to cover potential CDS obligations was a main reason for the failures at both Bear and AIG. Additionally, the hedge fund world is set to implode should CDSs fail in general.
--"The strongest drive is not love or hate. It is one person's need to edit another's copy."
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )entity it is there. Up front in the comments the institution will discus at length the efforts they take to manage their position.
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )n/t
--"The strongest drive is not love or hate. It is one person's need to edit another's copy."
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )nt
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )n/t
--"The strongest drive is not love or hate. It is one person's need to edit another's copy."
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )should provide the details to begin a conversationj but don't forget the footnotes.
and if you are dealing with insurance companies the statutory financials are exceptional.
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )all your work I assert that #127487 should be dismissed as not being neither persuasive or responsive to the issue at hand.
--Fence post turtles -- They don't get up there by themselves, some moron had to put 'em there.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )to fully explain it to you, I doubt...
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )Therefore we need to eradicate the notion that regulation is always bad, and eradicate it in a bi-partisan fashion.
--Fence post turtles -- They don't get up there by themselves, some moron had to put 'em there.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )was wrong but the inverse is equally as true.
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )to be explained in a manner average folk can understand.
Good regulation is good;
Bad regulation is bad; and
Figuring out which is which can be difficult.
--Fence post turtles -- They don't get up there by themselves, some moron had to put 'em there.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )see the conversations pursuant to Glass Stegal.
Bill, did you take the time to read the link? I believe you would find it interesting.
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )Buyers and sellers of derivative products should be required to hold a genuine interest in the underlying debt that is the subject matter of the contract and aggregate totals issues cannot exceed a party's interest in the underlying debt OR adequate cash collateral to cover the bet is on hand.
Violations would be potentially subject to criminal prosecution.
Credit default swaps are how the magnitude of a handful of subprime mortgages was increased by many many multiples through layers of speculation.
The mother of all check kiting scams (on steroids) appears to be the simplest explanation.
--Fence post turtles -- They don't get up there by themselves, some moron had to put 'em there.
- Login or register to post comments
)really, please show your calculations because I'm pretty sure you don't know what you are talking about.
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )unless you already own the instrument being hedged. Affiliated entity rules can be negotiated.
To hedge dubious debt (i.e. via CDS as insurance) is a legitimate business purpose.
Naked speculation via credit default swaps? Nope. It should be illegal.
--Fence post turtles -- They don't get up there by themselves, some moron had to put 'em there.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )nt
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )just do as I say" is a lousy way to get your way in a democracy.
The ability to explain complicated subjects in an easy to understand manner is a needful skill.
--Fence post turtles -- They don't get up there by themselves, some moron had to put 'em there.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )I would have to say you struggle with the fundamentals.
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )no one can force you to. However, having those points thereafter ignored is the most likely consequence of your decision.
--Fence post turtles -- They don't get up there by themselves, some moron had to put 'em there.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )first, "Buyers and sellers of derivative products should be required to hold a genuine interest in the underlying debt that is the subject matter of the contract", doesn't make any sense, you cannot be both long and short is the same tangible asset.
second and related, holding a "genuine interest" is an expansive not a limiting phrase.
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )mechanism to hedge debt. However, why should we permit such contracts if neither the buyer nor the seller of the CDS holds any interest in associated instrument?
How accurate is the following summary (wikipedia)?
Why should I be permitted to buy a credit default swap on Ford Motor Company corporate bonds (for example) if neither I nor the counter-party have a position in those securities?
If both the buyer and seller of credit default swap are strangers to the underlying debt instrument how is that deal different from taking InTrade positions on who will win the Presidential election? Or making sports book on whether the Rays defeat the Red Sox?
Farmers can and should be free to buy weather contracts (rainfall totals for example) at their own risk.
But unless such bets bear a reasonable relationship to the underlying reality (why should total issued credit default swaps be allowed to exceed the total face value of the associated debt instrument?) the potential exists for ridiculous levels of leverage which can rapidly collapse.
Thereafter, financial institutions that provide core liquidity needs for the global economy also should be prohibited from making such bets (except perhaps to hedge debt instruments they already own).
Okay, how is this wrong?
--Fence post turtles -- They don't get up there by themselves, some moron had to put 'em there.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )Why should I be permitted to buy a credit default swap on Ford Motor Company... Well what if you have a material exposure to a major supplier of FMC and you want to hedge your position but more importantly who gets to decide.
What if you sell the FMC bond are you required to sell the swap?
I have more scenarios, if you wish.
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )Anyway, reading links offers this:
The U.S is fortunate to benefit from such a foundation?
When nearly a trillion dollars in emergency taxpayer funding is needed to shore up the system, something is broken and part of the price tag attached to the bailout should be a clear and cogent explanation of what went wrong and why and how do we prevent a repeat performance in the future.
--Fence post turtles -- They don't get up there by themselves, some moron had to put 'em there.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )my diary on Freddie and Fannie is coming
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )needed to avoid accusations of an effort to lay smoke and shift blame.
--Fence post turtles -- They don't get up there by themselves, some moron had to put 'em there.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent ).
--The other day I heard that ignorance and apathy are sweeping the country. I didn't know that, but I don't really care.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )questions patiently? Are we certain we are talking about the same Timmy?
--Fence post turtles -- They don't get up there by themselves, some moron had to put 'em there.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )nt
--The other day I heard that ignorance and apathy are sweeping the country. I didn't know that, but I don't really care.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )this afternoon.
And it appears Wikipedia actually does offer a good elementary introduction to credit default swaps.
--Fence post turtles -- They don't get up there by themselves, some moron had to put 'em there.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )Many CDS buyers primarily buy them so they're both "long" and "short" on the same tangible asset. That's the whole point--you hedge the risk (going short) of owning the asset (going long).
Agreed on "genuine interest", though..that term could be tightened up a bit. I think what he's getting at (and forgive me if I'm wrong) is eliminating speculative CDS.
--"The strongest drive is not love or hate. It is one person's need to edit another's copy."
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )Defining "genuine interest" would require nuance and study.
My question is if both the buyer and seller of a credit default swap are total strangers to the associated debt instrument, how is that different than buying weather futures or maybe placing a bet on the Rays versus Red Sox series?
Yes, I can see how an auto parts supplier might wish to purchase CDS on Ford Motor Company corporate bonds (especially if the supplier sells only to Ford) however unless someone is minding the store on the total exposure being created in the entire market, unexpected fluctuations can cause huge crashes.
--Fence post turtles -- They don't get up there by themselves, some moron had to put 'em there.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )I get where you're going, I think.
I actually don't see the harm in speculative or pure investment uses of CDSs. They just need to be regulated and disclosed appropriately. That way, it would take most of the idiots out of the equation.
--"The strongest drive is not love or hate. It is one person's need to edit another's copy."
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )to the overall economy shouldn't be placing bets with people who cannot pay those bets if they lose. Nor should an institution which provides core liquidity needs place a bet it cannot afford to pay, if it loses.
The magnitude of the total bets also matters.
--Fence post turtles -- They don't get up there by themselves, some moron had to put 'em there.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )Which is why there should be a capital reserve requirement for CDS sellers and some form of public disclosure about the nature of and reason for buying and selling the contract.
--"The strongest drive is not love or hate. It is one person's need to edit another's copy."
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )nt
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )or even hundreds of billions of dollars into financial firms, being miserly with middle class and lower middle class mortgage lending and health benefits and unemployment compensation is a very short sighted position to take.
It risks populist uprisings that can kill this marvelous golden goose.
--Fence post turtles -- They don't get up there by themselves, some moron had to put 'em there.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )does a weather future make sense?
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )to be neutral
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )You're long and short on the same tangible asset.
--"The strongest drive is not love or hate. It is one person's need to edit another's copy."
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )although you now have counterparty risk.
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )Fence post turtles -- They don't get up there by themselves, some moron had to put 'em there.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )n/t
--"The strongest drive is not love or hate. It is one person's need to edit another's copy."
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )you've locked in your price.
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )but it's still semantics. You're both long and short, resulting in a neutral position. You stated you can't be both long and short in the same asset, and I wrote that, indeed, CDSs are used to be long and short on the same asset. It really is just semantics.
--"The strongest drive is not love or hate. It is one person's need to edit another's copy."
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )and you know that as well as I do. All such figures do need to be disclosed in public.
And that is why Paulson originally wanted NO review or oversight.
--Fence post turtles -- They don't get up there by themselves, some moron had to put 'em there.
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )or he remembers how review and oversight screwed up Fannie and Freddie.
--"Making sure your tires are properly inflated, simple thing, but we could save all the oil that they're talking about getting off drilling, if everybody was just inflating their tires and getting regular tune-ups. You could actually save just as much." Ob
- Login or register to post comments
| parent )